OPINION: Tweak needed in proposed data center regs 

Last week, the Hutchinson Planning Commission voted to recommend a set of data center zoning regulations to the Hutchinson City Council for future consideration.

You can read John McLaughlin’s coverage of the meeting elsewhere in this week’s Tribune for detailed information, but there are a few key things to know about the recommendations.

Standalone data centers would be categorized as micro-, small- or large-scale, based on size and, partly, electricity usage. Micro-scale would be limited to fewer than 5,000 square feet and 250 kilowatts of maximum electricity usage. That is one-third larger than the building The Tribune’s office is in, for comparison. Small-scale would be 5,000 to 99,999 square feet, and large-scale would be anything larger than that.

Micro-scale data centers would be allowed by right in C-3 and 4, I-1, 2 and 3 and A-I zoning districts. Small-scale would be allowed in I-1, 2 and 3 and A-I zoning districts but would require a conditional use permit, and large-scale data centers would only be allowed in the Kansas Enterprise and Kimbell industrial parks, also requiring a conditional use permit.

The recommended regulations would require closed-loop cooling, or more water-efficient cooling methods, and would ban evaporative cooling of data centers. They also would limit any data center to using 3.74 million gallons of water per month (about the equivalent of 1,000 homes, according to City Engineer Evan Patterson). Noise limits are included in the recommendations: 60 dBA—comparable to a normal conversation, according to Yale University Environmental Health & Safety—between 7 a.m. and 10 p.m., or 50 dBA—a bit quieter than a household refrigerator—from 10 p.m. to 7 a.m.

The recommended rules also require a written decommissioning plan and a bond or other financial guarantee for decommissioning when a data center shuts down.

With that out of the way, here is what we think of the planning commission’s proposal. We like the requirement for a decommissioning plan, and more than that, we like requiring a financial guarantee to guard against Hutchinson getting stuck cleaning up an old data center on the taxpayers’ dime. Data centers are a booming industry, but sometimes booms are followed by equally large busts. The technology is evolving rapidly, which puts data centers at risk of becoming obsolete. Requiring plans for decommissioning, and the money to accomplish that task, would be the smart thing to do.

And while we aren’t experts on water use caps or noise limits, it is good that the recommendations include safeguards for water use and noise.

Requiring a conditional use permit for all small- and large-scale data centers is good for transparency and public input, because every conditional use permit considered by the city must have a public hearing, and notice of that public hearing must be mailed to all property owners within 200 feet of the subject property (or 1,000 feet into the unincorporated area outside the city, if the property is adjacent to the city limit, as many of the industrial park properties are). Notice of a public hearing also must be published in the city’s official newspaper at least 20 days before the hearing.

So why wouldn’t the regulations extend the requirement of a conditional use permit to micro-scale data centers in the C-3 and C-4 zoning districts? C-4 zones include long stretches of East Fourth and East 30th avenues, as well as portions of West Fifth Avenue and North Main Street, all of which abut residential zoning districts. Not only that, but C-3 and C-4 zones can and do include homes: apartment buildings are permitted by right, while single-family homes, duplexes and loft apartments are allowed with a special use permit, like the one the planning commission (in its capacity as the board of zoning appeals) approved at the same meeting.

The city had an open house to gather public input for data center zoning rules in August, and two of the seven main themes from that, included in the packet for last week’s meeting, are that the public said, “Data centers should not be near our homes,” and “Residents want a say in what happens.”

Despite that input, if the Hutchinson City Council approves the regulations as recommended, the residents would have the least say in data centers closest to homes. For that matter, the planning commission and city council would have the least say on those data centers, as well. The planning commission makes a recommendation on every conditional use permit application, and the city council makes the final approval or denial decision.

If the city council likes the other elements of the recommended regulations, it should send them back to the planning commission to consider adding a conditional use permit requirement for micro-scale data centers in C-3 and C-4 zones.

– The Hutchinson Tribune Editorial Board

Tags from the story
0 replies on “OPINION: Tweak needed in proposed data center regs ”